Best Home Insurance in Indiana (2023)

Compare personalized Home insurance rates in Indiana

Home Insurance in Indiana

It’s always a good idea to refresh your homeowners insurance each year to make sure you always get the best price on it and to ensure you meet all Indiana homeowners requirements. Yet, for many people, the process is hard and takes time, which most do not have. The good news is that you can find homeowners insurance in Indiana that fits all of your needs with a bit more insight. To find cheap homeowners insurance, read these steps.

Home Insurance Companies in Indiana

The top-rated homeowners insurance companies in Indiana are capable of providing you with policies to match your risks and your needs. It goes without saying you need to be sure you are buying the right policy. To do that, work with homeowners insurance agencies in Indiana to learn about their suggestions. In addition, the best home insurance companies in Indiana will also provide you with money-saving discounts. It all comes down to working with independent home insurance agents in Indiana to get the best rates.

How to Get the Best Rates for Home Insurance in Indiana

How do you get started? To compare rates and find the lowest, enter your zip code here. You’ll get access to all of the available insurers in the area.


<zipcode>Find The Cheapest Home Insurance In Your Area:</zipcode>


How Much Does Homeowners Insurance Cost in Indiana?

Finding the cheapest home insurance in Indiana requires paying careful attention to what you are getting since policies are specific to the homes. The average annual premium in Indiana is $983. By comparison, the national average for the HO-3 policy is $1,173. Not everyone gets this low rate. To save, you need to get home insurance quotes in Indiana.


<twitter>The average annual premium in Indiana is $983. By comparison, the national average for the HO-3 policy is $1,173.</twitter>


List of Homeowners Insurance Companies in Indiana

To get quotes, fill in your zip code to the box on this page. You’ll receive a full list of companies to compare.

How Homeowners Insurance Is Calculated in Indiana

Costs are dependent on the home itself. Yet, some local information plays a role. To determine risk, insurers look at factors like the following.


<qa>1;Crime;Crime is a concern but is about average compared to the nation in Indiana. Property crime, which is the most important for insurance claims, has a crime rate score of 24.17 per 1,000 residents. Nationally, this rate is 24.</qa>

<qa>2;Weather/Climate;Whether is a concern in Indiana. The threats here involve high heat and droughts but also flooding and storm damage. The area also has the risk of tornados. This can increase the risk to property, raising your costs.</qa>

<qa>3;Home Values;The value of your home determines how much insurance you need. The higher the value is, the more coverage is required. The median home value in Indiana as of March of 2019 is $143,500. Values are growing. In the last year, home values have grown by nearly 11 percent.</qa>

Home Insurance Requirements in Indiana

Indiana home insurance can be complex, but these questions can give you some insight into what to expect. You should talk to your agent about other questions you have, too.

Is Homeowners Insurance Required in Indiana?

Legally, there is no requirement to maintain insurance. If you sign a contract with your mortgage lender agreeing to maintain coverage, though, you’ll need to do so. Most often, it is a financially sound investment.

What Does Home Insurance Cover?

Most homeowners need comprehensive home insurance. That’s the combination of liability insurance - to protect you against claims made by others - and property insurance which protects you against structural damage. It helps cover things like fires, storms, wind damage, and theft. If there is damage or loss to your possessions, those are covered, too.

Homeowners Insurance for New Properties in Indiana

New construction requires home insurance for most properties because mortgage lenders require it. Yet, a single fire can destroy your property, making home insurance a good investment for all home buyers.

Homeowners Insurance for Old Properties in Indiana

If you own an older property, you may decide not to get coverage. However, these properties still benefit from it. Consider lower coverage that may be more affordable if you want to save money.

Renters Insurance in Indiana

It is standard practice for landlords and property management companies to require renters to have renter’s insurance. This isn’t a legal requirement, but rather one the property owner puts in place.


Renter’s insurance in Indiana is typically under $30 a month depending on what type of property you rent. It protects your possessions and keeps you from having to pay the losses of someone who is hurt on your property.


<zipcode>Compare Renters Insurance in Indiana</zipcode>


Compare Home Insurance in Indiana by City

It’s up to you to get the cheapest home insurance in Indiana. To do so, compare home insurance quotes from numerous insurers. To give you some idea of what they may charge compared to the state’s average, consider these factors in the largest cities.


<qa>1;Home Insurance Quotes in Indianapolis, Indiana;With 863,002 people living in it, Indianapolis is the largest city and an urban, diverse community. It’s not surprising that the median home value is $142,900.</qa>

<qa>2;Home Insurance Quotes in Fort Wayne, Indiana;Fort Wayne is a growing city with a high quality of life and many amenities. It’s home to 265,904 residents. This city remains very affordable with homes valued at around $131,700.</qa>

<qa>3;Home Insurance Quotes in Evansville, Indiana;For those looking for a small town with a modern feel, Evansville fills that need. It has 118,930 residents. Home values in Evansville are very competitive at around $120,500.</qa>

<qa>4;Home Insurance Quotes in South Bend, Indiana;One of the most diverse and growing cities, South Bend has 102,245 residents. Even more affordable, the median home value here is $110,000.</qa>

<qa>5;Home Insurance Quotes in Carmel, Indiana;Smaller, but still a strongly residential community, Carmel is home to 92,198 people. Perhaps one of the fastest growing areas with new construction, the median home value here is significantly higher at $347,800.</qa>


Bonus: Most Expensive Homes in Indiana

You want the cheapest home insurance, but what if you lived in one of the most expensive homes in the state?


  • A 38,000-square foot home at 5501 W. Hamilton Rd. in Fort Wayne is valued at $30 million.
  • A home at 5799 Sunset Lane in Indianapolis has a value of $5.8 million.
  • Or, a new construction home at 64399 County Road 3 in Wakarusa is valued at $5 million.